Elliott Morris argues that focusing on the Iran War as a prime reason that Republicans got murdered two weeks ago at the polls is misguided. His support was cratering well before he launched the war. At the heart of his argument is the idea that there is no noticeable dip this past spring when he commenced hostilities. He goes on to argue that it was as much ICE and corruption as it was the specifics of the Iran War.
I think Morris might be making the same mistake as people who say, "Well it was the Iran War and rising gas prices." Josh Marshall has long advanced what he calls the Theory of Unitary Power. Basically, all political power is unified, and if you support drops in one area, it drops in others. This is how Biden's withdrawal from Afghanistan - a policy a majority of Americans supported, but a policy that looked like shit on the TeeVee - managed to collapse his approval across the board. His numbers falling on the economy don't make any sense if you were just upset about the images from Kabul.
In a way, this is just another way of saying that every election is about vibes. That's a bit broad, but...ok, yes. Kamala Harris was perceived as a far left California, woman of color, so Trump's bizarre "transgender for everyone" attack landed. There was little that Harris could do to reverse that engrained perception.
The break with Trump was not a single thing, but a rolling accumulation of outrages. There were the tariffs that rattled anyone with a working knowledge of taxes, trade or geography. There was the bizarre birthday parade he gave himself, the surging of National Guardsmen into American cities, the destruction of the East Wing, the government shutdown over health care. All of these things happened before Renee Good and Alex Pretti were gunned down on the streets of Minneapolis. That merely continued the downward slide.
Yes, the absolute collapse in support for Trump among Hispanics (not including Cubans and Venezuelans in Florida) can be attributed to ICE and the various abuses that they have committed. But that's happening at the same time as tariffs raising the prices at the store. It's happening at the same time he's fucking up the Reflecting Pool.
You don't see the swing that we saw from 2024 to 2026 because of a single reason. The real question is: What is Trump's floor? We know his ceiling is about 51%, and he'll never see that again. No, how unpopular can he get? I guess Stephen Miller, Howard Lutnick and Pete Hegseth are here to help us find out.