Capture The Flag

 Yglesias writes about how tawdry it is to have the 250th anniversary of independence tarnished by a man who has no conception of what actually made America great. Take Trump's assault on birth rite citizenship. That's not a policy debate about contours of immigration policy, it's an attack on a fundamentally American Idea: America is not a single people, it's an aspirational idea.

Trump has defiled so many basic ideas - about democracy, self-government, the rule of law, America's role in a dangerous world, that "all men are created equal" - that it's totally understandable to feel robbed of the opportunity to celebrate this great and flawed nation.

I guess I disagree. I think the celebration of the Declaration of Independence is more vital this year than if Harris had won and Trump was languishing in a prison cell. 

Of all the many ways that Trump has disgraced his office and our country, none are as profound than his assault on democracy itself. Before becoming President in 2017, Trump had never taken the oath of office - either as a soldier or public official - the first person ever to assume the office without first serving the country in some other way. In fact, Trump never even had to answer to a Board of Directors for most of his career. The idea of checks and balances is as foreign to him as the Nepalese language is. The recent string of Supreme Court cases have served to largely inoculate Trump from Congressional oversight or criminal consequences. 

What's more, Trump's cultists are not the sort of people who think in abstract, ideological terms. Democracy or the rule of law in the abstract are not as important as a "businessman who gets things done." When Trump promised to "be a dictator on Day One" that was a selling point for MAGA.

It is at this historical moment that we need to revivify the language and purpose of the Declaration. "Governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed" isn't as famous as "all men are created equal" but it's equally powerful and important as a hallmark of American political identity. 

I get why you might not feel like waving the flag this 4th of July. What you cannot do is cede the flag to a man whose every utterance is either an attack on America's founding principles or a verbal attack on America itself. How many times does Trump talk about how awful America is? He cannot go a day without denigrating some aspect of this country in ways that no other American president would even dream of doing. 

Do not let this creature destroy your love of what actually makes America great: the ability of the people to control their political destiny; the ability to create a "more perfect union" rather than accept the current limitations; the very real opportunity that this land and people have offered millions of immigrants to build a new and better life. 

If you let the shortcoming of this country define it for you - as quite a few leftist commentators tend to do - then you are basically doing the same thing Trump does: "We're no angels."

This country is far, far from perfect - no country is. But what is good about it is worth fighting for.