The Blue-nami that washed over the country two weeks ago overwhelmed the efforts of Republicans to draw House districts in such a way as to prevent Democrats from gaining control of that body. In fact, most of the districts that they drew to oust Democrats did not, in fact, oust Democrats.
In North Carolina, in particular, we saw a true dummymander, where Republicans diluted their own voting base to try and flip Democratic held seats. Carolina Blue was such that we saw a complete inversion of their intent. This doesn't mean the national gerrymander didn't work. What it did was prevent the Democrats from having an even larger majority. Democrats appear to have won the national popular vote by about 14 points. That's...a lot. But absent the gerrymander, it would have flipped even more seats.
Take North Carolina. First, you start with Trump's cratering approval ratings. Second, you take Roy Cooper's popularity and Michael Whatley's unpopularity creating a drag at the top of the ticket. Then - and only then - does the dummymander come into play.
Republicans were trying to draw an 11-3 map, and they did, but it will be 11 Democrats. Dig deeper and you will see the following:
- NC5 looks like it will be about 350 votes.
- NC3 looks like it will also be about 350 votes.
- NC 4 is about 4000 votes.
- NC 6 is about 6000 votes.
In a slightly more favorable environment, all of those are Republican wins and rather than 11-3, it's 7-7.
I'm not sure how the national Democratic Party can address this over Trump's veto. I'm not sure how it would get through the Senate. I'm not sure, for instance, if the House can simply write a rule for itself about gerrymandering. Article I, Section 5 of the Constitution says that "Each House shall be the Judge of the Elections, Returns and Qualifications of its own Members." Could they write a rule denying seats to states that gerrymander for partisan advantage? Does that come into conflict with the state sovereignty over the conduct of elections? What would even pass muster with this deeply corrupted Supreme Court.
There are obviously two outcomes in 2028.
The first is that Trump continues his slide into senescence and depravity, raking in corrupt money, enriching his family and cozying up to dictators. America continues to become dysfunctional - the way it has this past week - as complex systems fail and the cast of incompetent buffoons who staff the administration sit dumbly in the ashes of their failures. In this environment, we could expect a Democratic landslide in '28 that carries away even more Republican House and Senate members. I'd say the Democrats should be favored in the Senate races in Wisconsin and North Carolina, but Iowa and perhaps Indiana could be in play. (Indiana was another successful gerrymander, as Democrats won more votes, but Republicans won the House races 6-3.)
Of course, there's another, less possible outcome. Republicans manage to extricate themselves from Trump's corruption and incompetence and all that culture war shit reemerges. Maybe a culturally toxic leftist wins the Democratic nomination, and while they will still likely win, they won't sweep along the three Senate seats Democrats need to crush the filibuster.
Like so many other pressing issues, there is more to do than Congressional margins and Trump's veto will allow. When they DO get a trifecta, they need to remember that the will of the people is still being thwarted by these gerrymanders.
No comments:
Post a Comment