Blog Credo

The whole aim of practical politics is to keep the populace alarmed (and hence clamorous to be led to safety) by menacing it with an endless series of hobgoblins, all of them imaginary.

H.L. Mencken

Showing posts with label Shit Booman Says. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Shit Booman Says. Show all posts

Friday, September 18, 2026

How Big Is The Wave?

 There is emerging understanding that - even with the gerrymandering - the Democrats seem in great shape to take the House and maybe the Senate. Morris looks at how the big prognosticators tend to skew against the "out party" in the midterms. Basically, if you're the party out of power, the big raters like Cook and Sabato tend to underestimate the gains that you're going to make. In his analysis, "Toss Ups" aren't really toss ups at all, but lean to the out party by a lot. This could be important - if it holds - if these raters move more races into the toss-up category.

The other thing that seems to be happening is that Democrats tend to better when their actual candidates are polled as opposed to the generic ballot. Some of this is enthusiasm, but I think it also represents the fact that "Democrats" are an unpopular party, whose unpopularity is only exceeded (by a lot) by the Republicans. So, you have a lot of people saying that they don't necessarily support Democrats, that doesn't mean that they won't vote for Talarico. Democrats in red states are not a strong "brand" but individual candidates like Mary Peltola matter.

I don't want to suck on the hopium pipe like I did two years ago. Still, you have a rising confluence of events and a president who is weaker than he seems and historically unpopular. 

UPDATE: Martin Longman takes a victory lap on this.

Friday, June 26, 2026

Civic Education

 In his mailbag, Yglesias talks about "stealth democracy."

Stealth democracy is a theory that people have this idea that all that is required to solve a problem is for people of goodwill to sit down and hash out their disagreements like colleagues do. They see "corruption" as any action by a government that does not really benefit them. Sure, they can see things like Trump's desecration of the White House and DC in general as being "corrupt" for THAT reason, when the real reason is that he is accruing money to himself and his family and acting outside the cover of law. 

This misconception about "corruption" is really interesting. 

The elections in NYC are the flavor of the minute, and the factionalism expressed there is not an advantage for the Democratic Party in November. Adults - or at least people who really understand our politics and history - understand that you need a Big Tent to win elections, and what resonates in the congressional district around Columbia University does not resonate 25 miles to the north. Still, elements of the Left - and I do not really include Mamdani here - think that if a Democrat representing suburban Yonkers has a difference of opinion on, say, Israel, that isn't a difference of opinion. It's "corruption." They are corrupted by AIPAC.

(I need to take a moment and express my exasperation with the primacy of the Israeli-Palestine issue in Leftist politics at the moment. I fully support the idea that Israel has and continues to commit war crimes in Gaza and the West Bank; I do not think it is genocide, but I understand the arguments that it is. I fully support conditioning American military aid to Israel on the ousting of Netanyahu from power and Israel re-committing to a two-state solution. What I do NOT agree with, is that this is the most important issue facing this country. It is not in the top-10. Ultimately, much of the Israel-Palestine discourse feels performative, and that's just exhausting and not a path to winning control of Congress this fall. <end rant>"

Back to the issue at hand. So much of our politics - from MAGA to the DSA - seems fixated on a version of politics that is simply false. Yes, there is corruption, and Trump is so far and away our most corrupt president, that second place isn't even in the same league. You'd have to run through about 20 Trump scandals before landing on a previous scandal of similar depth. Most of those did not involve the direct participation of the president himself. Only Watergate rises to that level, maybe Iran-Contra. 

So, Trump is legit corrupt. When members of Congress disagree with each other, THAT IS NOT CORRUPTION. 

We've reached this perilous moment, because our parties are more ideological than perhaps they have ever been, and Trump adds breathless stupidity to the mix. The left of the Republican Party does not overlap with the right of the Democratic Party in any meaningful way. When they actually DO accomplish something, like Chris Murphy and James Lankford coming together to fix the immigration system, it gets blown up by Trump. The same thing could be happening with the bipartisan housing bill, but I think that has the votes to override Trump's veto. 

You've had this sort of venomous partisan discord since the '90s, but at least some of it was performative. That's the old "Senate Club" idea, where they yell at each other on CNN and then go have dinner together. Trump, because he has no saving graces or subtlety of thought, has turned that into a politics of grievance that has truly broken Congress and perhaps American democracy. Election denialism is really an offshoot of this. Democrats cannot legitimately win an election is not a position Newt Gingrich or Tom Delay would have entertained.

All of this is to say, we have to find a way out of this moment. 

People do not seem to understand the basics of how democratic governance and politics actually work. Hey, sometimes you lose an election! That's not corruption! Sometimes a good bill dies for bad reasons. That's not corruption! Sometimes there really aren't easy solutions to problems! That's not corruption! 

I've argued that we live in a consumer culture where we really don't have to compromise. You never have to go to Blockbuster only to find out the movie you wanted is checked out and then you have to compromise on whether to watch the rom-com or the action-buddy movie. You just click and stream. 

We've made much of our society frictionless and that simply isn't how politics works. Our whole system is based on friction! That's the point of the separation of powers. 

Instead, both the median voter AND the voters at the extremes simply decry the whole thing as "corrupt" because they can't get what they want all the time. 

That allows a demagogic troll to eviscerate our national institutions, just in time for the 250th anniversary of republican self-government. 

UPDATE: Slightly different take on the same issue of "corruption" from Martin Longman.

UPDATE II: Yet another take on the rise of "dirtbagism."

Wednesday, March 4, 2026

The Contingency Of History

 Martin Longman runs through a connection I had not known about. A critical moment in the history of Iran was the death of Ayatollah Khomeini, as it is often difficult to retain a revolutionary ideology after the charismatic leader of that revolution dies. It's what Max Weber referred to as the "routinization of charisma" and it's hard to pull off.

The logical successor to Khomeini was Ayatollah Hossein Montazeri. He was the most senior and respected cleric in Iran, and Khomeini's ideology required that the most senior cleric by in charge of the rule by religious authority. There was an friend of Montazeri named Mehdi Hashemi who was a complete asshole and got sideways of Khomeini, and that blew up in Montazeri's face.

I knew that this had happened, but I didn't know about Hashemi's role in this.

The reason this is important is that Montazeri was not completely wedded to the idea of the velayat-e faqih or rule by religious authority. He certainly wasn't a fan of trying to export the Iranian Revolution.

Ali Khamenei was.

In the span before his death, Khomeini worked with Ali Rafsanjanah - a nakedly cynical man - to elevate Khamenei over Montazeri. Khamenei was a revolutionary ideologue and Iran continued down the path that now has it as a pariah state at war with all of its neighbors.

I believe that history is largely about big forces, but individuals matter. What would have happened, for instance, if James Comey doesn't announce his investigation in Hillary Clinton's emails and/or the Stormy Daniels story gets out in October of 2016. What happens if Clinton wins is pretty obvious. Donald Trump never sniffs public office and America and the world is in a better place.

Friday, December 26, 2025

Yeah, That's Odd and Stupid and Dangerous

 Martin Longman notes something I noted when I heard it. Yesterday's strikes in Nigeria don't make a ton of sense geographically. Most of the ISIS/Boko Haram activity has been in northeast Nigeria, not the northwest. What's more, while we coordinated with the Nigerian government, that government does not want to make this a sectarian conflict. Nigeria works very hard but only somewhat successfully at keeping the idea of sectarian violence in the background. The Muslim/Christian divisions in the country are very strong and often violent, even without the psychopaths in Boko Haram making things worse.

It seems that if you want Trump to do something - as he did in this case - you just have to get it on Fox News. We heard this in his first administration; Trump doesn't (can't?) read, so he gets most of his "information" from the TeeVee. This is...suboptimal. This is why Hague-seth is Secretary of Defense and Tulsi Gabbard is DNI: they were on Fox.

This really is the stupidest timeline.

Monday, May 26, 2025

Trump and Hitler

 My working thesis is that Trump is not really a fascist, but many of the elements of MAGA and his administration are. Miller and Vought spring to mind, but all the "anti-woke" crusaders who want to programmatically destroy any vestige of cultural liberalism would qualify.

Martin Longman makes an interesting argument that Trump's similarities to Hitler are largely stylistic. He shares with Hitler a combination of "table thumping" ability with few core ideas beyond the roar of the crowds, which then becomes his core ideas. The wall with Mexico, for instance. Did Trump really believe that? Almost certainly not. But as we've seen time and time again, Trump says something stupid or false and that becomes the new litmus for MAGAts. 

Now, my reading of Hitler's rise is incomplete, but I don't think this tracks. Hitler very much had a program - some his, some from the others in the nascent Nazi Party. Both Trump and Hitler played the demagogue perfectly, but Trump's "policies" are really just the weird combination of prejudices he retains from the 1970s and '80s and whatever his crowds cheer to. My central critique of "Trump is a fascist" is precisely that fascism is programmatic and Trump is impulsive. The horrid people around Trump, however, absolutely have a program: Project 2025.

It's disorienting not knowing if America will rediscover its democratic spirit or even if we will be allowed to express that spirit in 2026. What happens if Trump and his minions actively try to end democratic elections? Not impede, but end? What happens as he continually defies court orders?

Trump can be horrific without being Hitler.

Sunday, January 5, 2025

A Governing Party Is A Legislating Party

 The inability of the Republican Party to pass anything approximating actual legislation is canon at this point. They cannot seem to pass any bills that command bipartisan support - which is necessary in the Senate - and so they try and push through odious base-stoking message bills through one house, but not the other. 

All of which raises the question about what they can actually accomplish. Martin Longman points out the problems with their current strategy and House margins. Trump wants a "big bill" because of course he does, the big man-baby. The problem can be seen in the Speaker election. In order to certify Trump's victory, the House needed a Speaker, so whatever reservations hardliners and moderates (such as they are) might have to Mike Johnson, they came together to get Trump certified.

Once it comes time to pass a bill that will do all sorts of terrible fucking things, keeping all those whackjobs in line will be challenging. In the story Longman cites, there's the following quote from Jason Smith, the Chairman of Ways and Means: "Just look at history, the Democrats couldn't even do it."

I guess, maybe, Smith is suggesting that the Democratic Party is some sort of borg-like entity. In fact, the reason why Democrats can usually pass bills, is because they have a functional ability to negotiate ahead of the votes. Once Stefanik and Waltz join the Executive Branch, the ability to corral the needed votes in the House will be nearly impossible. 

Trump will still be able to launch his trade war and do his deportations without a lot of Congressional help. He will still be able to enrich himself at the public's expense. However, it will be really tough to actually pass bills that have a long term impact on people. 

Hopefully.

Wednesday, October 4, 2023

Interesting Take

 This TPM reader makes a case for Democrats propping up McCarthy's Speakership. Like Marshall, I'm not sure I agree with it, because McCarthy had basically shown himself to be a liar when it came to deals he made with Democrats. The argument that it would put Democrats in the driver's seat is an interesting one, though. If Democrats had saved McCarthy, would that mean McCarthy would do things like pass a reasonable budget or fund Ukrainian aid? I suppose it's possible, but that seems very unlikely. 

It is reasonable to wonder what comes next, though. Conceivably a new Speaker (who isn't a Freedumb Caucus troll) could be elevated by Democratic votes and attain the same result. McCarthy was just the worst reed for anyone to lean on - a weak man void of principles.

The general idea that Democrats are responsible for cleaning up the GOP's mess is absurd though. If this causes some pain, perhaps that it the lesson that Americans need about a year from yet another Most Important Election Ever.

Martin Longman makes the case against this argument. Mainly, his argument is that there IS a functional and functioning majority in the House, but it consists of mostly Democrats. McCarthy seemed to think he could shit on that and survive. He could not. Is there a Speaker who could win 5-10 Republican votes? I think a Speaker Liz Cheney would be freaking hilarious.

All of this brings to mind the superiority in so many ways of a parliamentary system. If we were in a parliamentary system, we would be having elections to fix this bullshit. We don't so we aren't. We are stuck with this clown car for another 15 months.

Sunday, August 6, 2023

Quick, To The Hypothetical Mobile!

 We have Yglesias' intern and Martin Longman both take a look at what sort of Republican can beat Trump. Maya Bodnick's take is that Vivek Ramaswamy is taking the optimal approach of presenting Trumpist policies in traditional political language. As we've seen with DeSantis, the bullying approach really only works for Trump, a fact that Longman's analysis explains. For Longman, any credible challenger needs to be fundamentally different than Trump in some important ways.

I don't think that the replacement for Trump stands much of a chance in 2024. Obviously, Trump could die; he's old and looks like a boiled sheep's stomach. Even more likely, he could be in jail before the convention. I suppose that there is a chance that if he's in jail, it makes sense to be DeSantis and offer your Dollar General version of Trumpism. 

Of course, there's the most likely outcome, which is that Trump moves heaven and earth to delay the 1/6 trial and somehow pulls it off. in which case he's the nominee. 

The truly interesting scenario is the one where he's in jail and decides to run anyway. Obviously a pardon would be his only hope, so would he try and continue his quixotic quest to return to the presidency and pardon himself? Or would he throw his weight behind a Republican who promised to pardon him, if he won?

The Republican caterwauling about this, of course, obscures a fundamental difference between Republicans and Democrats, that I think goes back to Reagan. Look, I think Joe Biden is a decent human being and remarkably effective president for this moment in our history. But, if Biden wasn't running I could quite easily throw my support behind a Buttigieg or a Whitmer or a Pritzker or a Booker or so on and so on. What matters, fundamentally, is that the Democratic Party stands for a set of principles and policies that I agree with. I want Dobbs overturned; I want meaningful action on climate change; I want meaningful restrictions on gun ownership; I want more progressive taxation and more efforts to reduce poverty.

Republicans want a strong man. Policies? Who gives a fuck? We want the strong man who will make the Democratic boogeyman angry and go away. The nature of the authoritarianism that has always been present in the American Right naturally adheres to singular individuals. What's interesting about Trump is that when the Bushes left office, they were unpopular for different specific reasons. Bush pere was unpopular because he raised taxes; Bush fils was unpopular because Iraq and the economy melted down. In other words, they betrayed the "ideas" of the GOP. The GOP has no more real "ideas" that you can really point to. 

Trump was beaten soundly in 2020, but that's no longer disqualifying. This is profoundly worrying, because it means that the GOP will struggle to correct its course back to being a center-right party. You have to learn from your defeats, and the Trumpist GOP refuses to admit it lost.

So who will be the 2024 nominee if it isn't Trump? If he's dead or in prison? Maybe it will be Ramaswamy, but do we really think that the Trumpenproletariat are going to to vote for a guy named Ramaswamy?

Finally, let's take the internal arguments of the Trumpists at face value: Trump actually won in 2020. The biggest predictor of an incumbent losing re-election is a stiff primary challenge. (Roosevelt in 1912; Kennedy in 1980; Buchanan in 1992) Trump doesn't exactly have a "stiff" primary challenge, but he does face a fractured party. However, what allowed him to win in 2016 was a divided field, which is what he faces again.

Bernie Sanders rose to prominence in 2016 because he was the Not Hillary candidate. There isn't a singular Not Trump candidate on the GOP side (Hutchinson and Christie are dividing that role, and the others just mimic him.). If one emerges? That's the person who will take the mantle from Trump if he cannot run. If he can, it's him.

Saturday, June 3, 2023

Biden

 I agree with pretty much everything Martin Longman says here. From Biden, I wanted competency and an end to the chaos and drama of Trumpistan. We got that. I also agree that it's a shame that Biden has largely done everything we could have hoped from him and maybe more and his approval ratings continue to be so aggressively meh.

I suppose it's the curse of being a work horse and not a show horse, when all the reporters are looking for the show horse.

Friday, January 21, 2022

Martin Longman Is Bummed

 He points out that he (and others, including yours truly) predicted that governing with the "trifecta" was still going to be difficult, because of the filibuster and Joe Manchin. Right. In fact, I think the problem is that Biden actually DID accomplish quite a bit, but his recent efforts on BBB and voting rights have failed. That erases whatever memories we have of his remarkably successful first few months.

I've argued that specific legislative victories are not the key to winning elections, and I stand by that. Biden's approval ratings are low because the pandemic won't go away, and people are generally bummed. The economy is actually pretty good right now and likely to stay strong. There is the possibility of Ukraine blowing up, I guess, but I feel like this is more Putin's brinksmanship than a prelude to full scale war.

In short, I remain bullish on the midterms for two reasons.

First, it's a long way to November. I anticipate that - barring new variants - Covid will become largely endemic by spring. We are already treating it as an endemic disease here on campus, because we are entirely vaccinated. Kids get sick, they go home. Just like with the flu. If the pandemic truly wanes away into background noise, people will feel better about things and they will have six months to change their minds.

Second, the GOP's gerrymandering and turnout advantages might be tapped out. The electoral maps do not appear to wipe out Democratic hopes to hold the House. It still is the most likely outcome, but see point #1. I think we will see major indictments up and down the ranks of former Trump Administration figures. Trump will explode and that - combined with the perverse incentives created by GOP vote suppression - could be enough to drive Democratic voters to the polls. To do this, Biden and Democrats will need to secure those suburban votes that they won in 2018 and 2020. The Senate map looks decently favorable, again if the pandemic can recede. 

Will a GOP wave happen? Possibly. But to capitulate now is bad.

Wednesday, December 15, 2021

We Are All Burkeans

 Martin Longman talks about "popularism" and the burdens that Democrats labor under in terms of an asymmetric playing field.

Basically, without saying it, what Longman is describing is temperamental as opposed to ideological conservatism. America is not a "center right" nation when it comes to policy preferences. Ask Americans what they would like, and their views will largely line up with a broad range of "center left" priorities. Of the top of my head, majorities support some form of abortion rights, more gun control, higher taxes on the rich, more government help with health insurance, a better environment, improved public education, workplace protections...I dunno, I'm still ingesting my coffee. Ask them if they "want" these things and anywhere from 51% to 70%  will say, "sure." 

Here's what I think Longman hits on. When you craft your question a certain way, you get a certain answer. If you say, "Anyone should be able to get an abortion whenever they want," that won't be popular. If you say, "Abortion in the first trimester should be available to those women who need it." it will be.

This semantics argument is at the heart of "popularism." That there's some magical phrasing that will make Democrats an enduring majority party.

What Longman hits on, and I think this is more profoundly important than he realizes, is that ANY CHANGE will be unpopular compared to preserving existing structures. At first, this is really discouraging for a party that wants to improve things for most Americans. If you do something like Obamacare, you will get punished for it, because change is scary.

The flip side is that once you've instituted those changes, they become the status quo that becomes hard to change. We saw this with the Affordable Care Act. The GOP had control of both chambers of Congress and the Presidency and they couldn't gut the law. Bush couldn't gut Social Security. 

The temperamental deference to the status quo is a fairly normal human impulse. So how do Democrats navigate this?

First, the wasted time with Manchinema really does hurt more than I thought it would. Not because of the dysfunction narrative - though it doesn't help when you're trying to sell efficient government and they can't function efficiently. Rather any gains that Democrats want to run on in 2022 and 2024 require people understanding exactly what the new status quo is and Democrats effectively saying that they want to protect that.

In other words, you win an election; you issue reforms quickly; Republicans howl about the reforms; Democratic poll numbers drop; people like the reforms; Democrats run on protecting them from Republicans.

What I worry about is that a two year cycle simply isn't long enough to allow this process to give the Democrats working majorities for long enough to truly cement their gains.

If - somehow - Democrats can run and win in 2022 on a fear of a Trump Restoration and the end of democracy as we know it - then there is real hope for creating a virtuous cycle for enough time to bleed off support for Cult 45.

Tuesday, February 2, 2021

We Have A Christianist Problem

 Martin Longman shows how closely Trumpism and 1/6 is tied to White Evangelical Christian Nationalism. It's an excellent read as to why "Christians" supported a twice divorced serial sexual predator who couldn't tell Isaiah from Jeremiah. At the root of Christian Nationalism is a preference for authoritarianism that supports their worldview: a blinkered, bigoted reaction against the fact that America is changing to be a more tolerant, diverse place.

Please read.

Sunday, November 29, 2020

The Politics Of Resentment

 I came across this piece in Vox about how Asian American communities - while voting 2 to 1 for Biden - have been inundated with actual fake news. Because "Asian American" includes a wide variety of ethnic groups, from Vietnamese to China to Taiwan to Korea...that's a lot of cultural and historical difference. 

A lot of (white) Progressives assumed that Trump's naked racism and xenophobia would repel immigrant groups across cultural divides. They tended to neglect the impact of "Biden is a socialist" on communities that have a large number of people who fled communism. Florida Cubans have always trended towards the GOP, but Venezuelans have the same dynamic. Those same trends apply to many Asian American groups.

What's interesting is the advent of Epoch Times, a news organization tied to the Falun Gong exercise cult. While Falun Gong are...weird...the amount of persecution they have suffered at the hands of the Chinese Communist Party is appalling. Still their virulent opposition to the CCP has led them to embrace Far Right Populism from Germany, France to Trump. Like many aspects of the Far Right, the Epoch Times/Falun Gong movement feeds on resentments without actually properly identifying the accurate source of those resentments.

The focus on resentment feeds into something called "relative deprivation theory." Basically, revolutionary movements feed off the gap between where people are and where they think they should be. In the US, this accounts for why the Rose Twitter Socialists are largely college educated podcasters from Brooklyn. They live in one of the more affluent countries in the world in a time of relative abundance and yet the gap between what they expected and what they have is so large, they want a "revolution" that will overturn a system that seems to hold their dreams at an arm's length.

This politics of resentment isn't inherently constructive or positive. It is - at its roots - negative. It is also non-ideological and can be grafted onto the Democratic Socialists of America as easily it can be wedded to Trumpism. It can apply to Falun Gong political refugees in Orange County as easily as it can Marine Le Pen's National Front in France.

What's more, the politics of resentment finds objective, balanced truths unimportant. Anger and fear are emotions that chew up reason. Since reason ideally sits in the center of democratic governance, the natural alliance between groups like the Epoch Times and Donald Trump is disturbing.

The good news, if there is any, is that there remains potential growth for Democrats among groups that have been fed a steady diet of resentment and fear. Biden is not a scary socialist and many that lauded Trump because their stock portfolios were doing well are not likely to be upset by a Biden Administration. Incumbents usually win, because things aren't usually THAT bad. 

Combatting the end of objective truth is a tall order for a political movement, but that is where we are. Despite the efforts of groups like the Epoch Times, Biden DID still win close to 2/3rds of Asian American votes. Twitter basically started flagging Trump's tweets as lies, as did mainstream media outlets. The next question is how to bring factual accountability to Facebook and other news aggregators. People who want to watch OANN or read Breitbart...they are lost causes. Fighting the casually misinformed is a necessity for the political survival of democracy.

UPDATE: Martin Longman has a slightly different, but more profound take.

Wednesday, May 13, 2020

Knew This Was Coming

Republicans (The Pro Life Party!) are rushing to open the economy before we are ready to do so.  We know that there is not enough testing in place and basically no tracking apparatus, even if we had the testing. We are flying blind with a national government that doesn't give a shit.

As some places re-open we have every reason to expect that cases and deaths will increase. There is a non-zero chance that we won't see a huge case, except in other tightly packed urban areas like NYC.  And since those people are mostly Democrats, the GOP is fine with them dying. But the most likely thing we will see is a spike in cases across the red states that are re-opening.

How will the GOP spin this? A supermajority of Americans don't want to rush to re-open the economy before it's safe to do so, and if we see a huge second wave of deaths, the blame will fall on the GOP and the economic recovery won't happen.  What will the GOP do?

Lie about the numbers. We know Trump admires dictators like Putin and Xi, and they are almost certainly lying about their numbers, so why not do that here? It will take sustained attention from the media to force various government entities to be transparent. The GOP death cult has a powerful incentive to undercount the numbers, even if most epidemiologists believe we are dramatically UNDER counting the current Covid-19 death toll.

The problem is that while statistics are somewhat important, narratives are more important.  If 10 people in your small town die, and you know two of them, it's a failed pandemic response. If 100 people in the next state die and you don't know any of them...well, that's sad I guess. It's when the local news starts showing freezer trucks being used to haul away the dead that no amount of spin from DC will make an impact on people.

Trump has always believed he can bullshit his way through unflattering facts.  The virus doesn't give a shit about his bullshit.

UPDATE: Martin Longman posits how the current outbreak in the White House itself would normally be a wake-up call, but with this crew....

Wednesday, February 26, 2020

Exactly This

Martin Longman explains the unique vulnerability of Bernie Sanders.  Perhaps Sanders can simply ride opposition to Trump into both the White House and Congressional majorities in both houses.  More likely he creates chaos up and down the ticket and costs Democrats otherwise defensible seats.

Trump offered the Democrats an opportunity that they fully exploited in 2018: winning the suburbs. The GOP's descent into the party of Donald Trump and Mike Pence could allow for the Democrats to fashion a true governing coalition of African Americans, most Hispanics and Asians, young voters, single women and college educated whites. What's uniquely perverse about Sanders is that he seems intent on alienating various parts of that coalition.  Instead he's banking on massive youth turnout, and that has always been a poor bet.

Friday, October 11, 2019

Layers Upon Layers

Martin Longman has been in the weeds of this more than I have, but if he's calling this the biggest scandal in US history, I'd pay attention.  Certainly there is an inordinate amount of smoke surrounding Rudy Giuliani.

It's corruption all the way down.

Wednesday, April 17, 2019

The Future Liberals Don't Want

Martin Longman lays out the startling argument that Democrats are likely headed to a brokered convention. Ultimately, this is why Biden feels like he has to jump in, and might wind up consolidating his choice.  Few people within the party want Bernie Sanders to be the nominee.  But in a badly fractured field, no one would wind up winning the nomination.  That would lead to a brokered convention, and - as Longman notes - the Russians and GOP would turn the simmering embers left over from 2016 into a bonfire.

I'm sure all the lower tier candidates are hoping to catch fire the way people like Buttigieg have.  If your Corey Booker, you're hoping that "something happens" to catapult you into relevancy.  But at some point, you're not helping.  When do Gillibrand, Booker, Castro, Swalwell, Yang, Inslee and the others pack it in?  If it's after New Hampshire, it could be too late.

Sunday, January 13, 2019

As I Was Saying

Martin Longman lays out the case that the FBI and CIA have been on Trump as a Russian asset all along, and that we shouldn't be surprised.

Basically, what I said yesterday, but with more evidence and documentation.

Thursday, December 27, 2018

Is He Though?

I respect the hell out of Martin Longman's political insights, but he's suggesting that the current allegations of proof that Michael Cohen visited Prague and met with Russians during the campaign could be the end of the line for Trump. There's some suggestion that Mueller knows this, Trump knows Mueller knows this and this is why Trump has been freaking out. 

But I will remain skeptical that there is anything Trump can do that would cause 20 Republican Senators to remove him from office.  They are simply too afraid of their own voters.

Monday, October 8, 2018

The Long View

I vacillate these days from being a political science teacher and a history teacher.  Not pedagogically, but how I look at the world. 

The political science teacher looks at Trump and the GOP and sees a descent into racial hatred and demagoguery, corruption and authoritarianism.  The GOP enjoys - for the moment - a demographic advantage in the Senate and series of natural and artificial gerrymanders in the House.  This has allowed a minority of Americans to elect a manifestly unsuitable president, a Congress that has no consideration of the opinions of the majority of Americans and a Supreme Court that thinks the 1880s were too liberal.

The history teacher would note that America has always had racist demagogues, the politics of division and a strain of authoritarianism.  I'm a fan of Edmund Morgan's thesis that racism and slavery allowed democracy to take root in America, because white Americans enjoyed a relative equality vis a vis African slaves.  And for much of American history, whites have excluded minorities from political power.  The election of Obama didn't end this, so much as create a virulent rearguard action to preserve white supremacy.  We've done this before, walked this road.  We came out the other side and we should again.

Unless... and I hate to even type these words... if Democrats have been so gerrymandered out of power that election day does not bring at least one House of Congress into Democratic control... As Josh Marshall notes, breaking all the rules worked.  It worked for Trump.  It worked for McConnell.  It has now worked for Kavanaugh.  Every branch of the federal government is under Republican control, because they broke the rules and a minority of Americans is able to force their will upon the majority.

If that doesn't change, then we are headed for a very dark place.