Early on election night, I realized that my optimistic appraisal of the American electorate was badly flawed and that Trump would likely win. I drove out into the woods and screamed in rage and despair into the darkness. I wasn't sure how bad it would be, but I knew that the country had rejected decency and law in favor of a flawed view of the economy of 2019.
So far, it has been objectively bad, but bad in a way that I think we can recover from. Yes, the Big Ugly Bill is a horror show; yes, people are being hurt; yes, the economy is being skewed even more towards the rich. You can point to dozens of terrible things this administration is doing or planning on doing.
Yet, those actions can be undone. Bad bills can be replaced with good bills. America and the world will be worse off because Trump was returned to office, but the world is a resilient place and given time and the opportunity, we can return to a better state of affairs.
The gerrymandering plan being forced on Texas is shaking me up.
Abbott has always struck me as a less charismatic version of Trump. He lacks the gonzo appeal Trump apparently has for many, but he has the same anti-democratic impulses. When Trump asked him to redistrict, he rushed to do so. Texas Democrats have fled the state to deny Republicans a quorum, and now Abbott is talking about stripping them of their seats. Is that legal? I don't know, but I doubt that will stop him.
As Krugman notes, this is a sign of Trump's desperation. Republicans in Trumpistan do measurable worse when he's not on the ballot. The House is razor thin anyway, and every seat could matter in 2026. Forcing mid-decade redistricting on Texas, Florida and Ohio is a blatant attempt to short circuit democratic accountability.
If it succeeds, that's the ball game. Seriously. I don't see how the country hangs together. We either become a dictatorship or the country fractures. Democrats have to win control of at least one house of Congress in order to exercise a check on the Mad King. If they fail to win either the House or Senate, then all the malevolent bullshit will become the new American normal. I doubt very much whether we would have anything approaching free and fair elections in 2028.
Now, there is another possibility. The descent into authoritarianism has - at least nominally - stayed within the bounds of law. So far, we don't have evidence of tampering with the counting of ballots. Putin and Orban didn't skew the counting, they just shaped the elections in ways that insured their victories. Gerrymandering is from that playbook.
The Supreme Court enabled this with the Rucho decision that forbid Federal courts from overturning partisan gerrymandering. Even in that decision, they agreed that gerrymandering might be undemocratic, but that they had no power to intervene. The Texas gerrymander almost certainly violates the Voting Rights Act, but does anyone expect the Courts to uphold that law? Roberts has been trying to overturn it since the the 1980s.
Now, as of this writing, California is thinking about changing their laws to gerrymander that state out of Republican hands. Illinois could do the same. New York...well, they are making the proper noises, but the NY Dems always fuck up, and in fact, fucked up a gerrymander attempt in 2021.
A gerrymander war could preserve the chances of a Democratic House. There is even the chance that Republicans will create a "Dummymander" (a phrase I just heard) whereby they take districts that Trump won by 10 points and make the 5 point Trump districts. In a wave election, Democrats might win those seats. Right now, Republicans have gerrymandered Texas to create their partisan map. Texas' 3rd, 12th, 15th, 21st, 23rd, 24th, 26th, 31st and 38th districts are all already R+11 or closer. Dilute those at all and a backlash election could tilt the map to Democrats - even in Texas.
However, the gerrymander war or even the dummymander would mean that Republicans could reach for more extreme measures to preserve their rule. Krugman's conclusion is scary, but accurate:
And what if these actions aren’t enough? Remember, Trump supporters, with his clear encouragement, already tried to overturn the results of the 2020 election.
The important point is that right now Trump has immense power, thanks in large part to the cowardice of many of the institutions that should be holding him in check. But he’s also rapidly bleeding support, in large part because he’s completely failing to deliver on his economic promises.
That combination makes this an extremely dangerous moment. And if authoritarianism does come to America, don’t count on it being soft.
They are telling us how little respect they have for democracy. They said it when they refused to vote for impeachment after January 6th. They said it when they renominated Trump. They said when they rolled over for his awful legislation and illegal power grabs. They are saying by launching this gerrymander war.
If they succeed in gerrymandering Texas, Florida and Ohio even more, and Democrats match them or they dummymander their way out of the majority in a wave election, why should we imagine that Trump and his fascist hangers on will accept that result peacefully?